Sikkim · India travel tipsChopta Valley Travel Guide
The kind window is spring, about April to June , for the alpine bloom, and autumn, about October to November , for the clearest skies. Winter freezes the valley and can shut the...
NORTH SIKKIMTSOPTA VALLEYLACHENUPDATED JUN 2026
01Season
When to visit Chopta Valley in North Sikkim
The kind window is spring, about April to June, for the alpine bloom, and autumn, about October to November, for the clearest skies. Winter freezes the valley and can shut the road, and the monsoon brings landslides.
- Spring, about April to June: the bloomThis is when the barren valley comes alive. Primulas, rhododendrons and countless small alpine flowers colour the slopes around Thangu and Chopta, and the birding is at its best. Days are pleasant lower down but mornings at 13,000 feet stay cold, so carry warm layers even in June.
- Autumn, about October to November: clear skiesAfter the monsoon clears, the air is crisp and the mountain views are at their sharpest. The valley is not in flower now, but the light and the visibility are the best of the year, and the road is usually stable before the snow sets in.
- Winter, about December to March: snow and closuresThe valley freezes and the rivers turn to ice, which is beautiful, but heavy snowfall from about December to February can block the road for days at a time. Temperatures in the Lachen belt drop to about minus 5 to 15 degrees Celsius, so come only with proper cold-weather gear and a flexible plan.
- Monsoon, about July to September: avoidThe North Sikkim road is fragile and prone to landslides in the rains, and this is the season most likely to strand you or cancel the high leg. It is the one window we would steer you away from for this route.
The one thing to reconfirm before you bookChopta Valley itself stays reachable in the open seasons, and its famous neighbour Gurudongmar Lake reopened to tourists from about March 2026 after more than two years shut following the 2023 glacial lake outburst flood, once a new bailey bridge over the Taram Chu restored the Lachen road. The road is still fragile, though, so the lake sees short weather and landslide closures, especially in the monsoon. Because Chopta is often sold as part of a Gurudongmar trip, check the current lake status with your operator and the Sikkim Tourism site before you commit to dates, and keep a spare day for a road block.
02Air, rail and road
How to reach Chopta Valley and Lachen
There is no direct way in. You fly or train to the plains, drive up to Gangtok, then take the long mountain road to Lachen, the base village for the whole Chopta and Gurudongmar leg.
- Fly to Bagdogra, then driveBagdogra airport near Siliguri is the nearest airport, about 124 km and roughly 4 to 5 hours by road from Gangtok along the Teesta river highway. It has the widest connections from Delhi, Kolkata and other cities, and is where almost every North Sikkim trip begins.
- Train to New JalpaiguriNew Jalpaiguri, or NJP, is the nearest big railway station, about 125 km and roughly 4 to 4.5 hours from Gangtok. It is well connected to Kolkata, Delhi and the rest of the country, and pairs neatly with the road leg up to Gangtok.
- Gangtok to Lachen, the long mountain legFrom Gangtok it is about 107 km and roughly 5 to 6 hours of slow mountain driving to Lachen, crossing Chungthang where the North Sikkim permit belt begins. Lachen, at about 8,800 feet, is where you sleep before the early run up to Chopta, Thangu and, for Indians, Gurudongmar.
- There is no independent way inYou cannot self-drive or take a public bus into this belt. North Sikkim beyond Chungthang is permit-only and must be done through a registered operator in a Sikkim-registered vehicle, so the drive is arranged as part of your tour, not booked on the day.
From the US, UK and Europe
Fly into Delhi or Kolkata, connect to Bagdogra, then drive up to Gangtok and on to Lachen with your registered operator. Remember your permit as a foreign national takes you only as far as Thangu and Chopta Valley, not Gurudongmar.
From the Gulf and Southeast Asia
Fly into Kolkata or Delhi, then to Bagdogra, and continue by road. Build in the extra day the altitude needs rather than rushing the whole loop in a weekend.
Within India
Fly or train to Bagdogra or NJP, drive to Gangtok, and arrange the North Sikkim leg through a Gangtok operator who handles your permit. The Bagdogra and NJP gateways are the simplest way in.
03First, which Chopta
Which Chopta is this, and what the valley actually is
Before anything else: this is Chopta Valley in North Sikkim, a treeless high valley near Thangu on the Gurudongmar road, not the forested Chopta in Uttarakhand with Tungnath and Chandrashila. Here is how to tell them apart and what you actually see.
Two different Choptas, hundreds of miles apartIf you came looking for Tungnath, Chandrashila and the meadow campsite, that is Chopta in Uttarakhand, a forested ridge at about 8,790 feet in the Garhwal Himalaya and the trekking base for the Panch Kedar. This page is the other Chopta: Chopta Valley, sometimes spelled Tsopta, in North Sikkim, a treeless alpine valley at about 13,100 feet near Thangu village on the road to Gurudongmar Lake, which you can reach only on a permit tour. If you wanted the trekking Chopta, see our separate Chopta, Uttarakhand guide.
- A barren, high, exotic valleyUnlike the green of lower Sikkim, Chopta Valley is austere and treeless, ringed by bare high ridges. That starkness is the point; it feels like the roof of the country rather than a garden, and the sense of altitude and space is what people remember.
- The spring transformationFor a short window in spring the valley floods with primulas, rhododendron shrubs and unnamed alpine blooms, and the slopes turn colourful almost overnight. This is also the birding season around Thangu and Chopta, roughly April into May.
- Thangu, the village just belowThangu village, about 35 km from Lachen, is the last real settlement before the high valley. Many tours pause here for a simple hot lunch, sometimes in a villager's hut, before the short detour up to Chopta itself.
- The gateway to GurudongmarChopta Valley sits on the way to Gurudongmar Lake, so for Indian travellers it is usually a stop on the drive up or back. For foreign travellers it is the turnaround point, the furthest north a foreign passport is allowed on this road.
04The permit rules
Permits for North Sikkim, Chopta Valley and Gurudongmar
This is the part that decides your whole trip. North Sikkim is permit-only, cannot be done independently, and the rules are different for Indian and foreign passports. Read this before you plan anything else.
- Permit-only, and no independent travelNo one, Indian or foreign, may go north of Chungthang towards Lachen, Thangu, Chopta Valley or Gurudongmar without a Protected Area Permit. The permit is issued only to travellers on a booked itinerary with a Sikkim Tourism registered operator, in a Sikkim-registered vehicle, with a driver who holds the North Sikkim beat permit. You cannot self-drive or go solo.
- For Indian nationals: the free PAPThe Protected Area Permit for Indians is free of cost and usually arranged in a day by your Gangtok agent through the Tourism Department and the police check post. Carry a government photo ID such as Voter ID, Passport or Driving Licence and two passport photos. Note that Aadhaar is often not accepted as the primary ID for this permit, so bring a Voter ID, Passport or Driving Licence.
- For foreign nationals: the Restricted Area PermitForeigners need a Restricted Area Permit arranged through a registered Sikkim travel agent, and it is not granted to a lone traveller: you must apply as a group of two or more. The stay is capped at 30 days, extendable in total to 60, and the North Sikkim permit runs a minimum of 3 days and 2 nights up to a maximum of 5 days and 4 nights, supervised by a registered guide.
- The hard foreigner limitA foreign passport can travel only as far as Thangu and Chopta Valley. Gurudongmar Lake is open to Indian nationals only, because it sits close to the Indo-China border, and there are no exceptions. If reaching the lake is your dream and you hold a foreign passport, know this before you book, so Chopta becomes the goal rather than a disappointment.
Carry originals, and reconfirm the processPermit rules in a border region change, and the process for foreign nationals has been moving to digital clearance. Carry original IDs, not just photocopies, keep several passport photos, and let your registered operator handle the paperwork. Always reconfirm the current permit process and any Gurudongmar closure with your operator and the official Sikkim Tourism site close to your travel date.
05What to actually do
Signature experiences around Chopta Valley
The valley is not about ticking sights; it is about high, quiet, empty beauty. Here is what people remember, and how each changes with the season.
- Stand in the high, empty valleyThe core experience is simply being at about 13,100 feet in a treeless valley ringed by bare peaks, with the wind and the light and very few other people. Give it time, walk gently because of the altitude, and let the scale of the place settle.
- The spring bloom and the birdingIn spring the slopes around Thangu and Chopta fill with primulas and rhododendrons, and it becomes a birding hotspot roughly April into May. If wildflowers or Himalayan birds are your reason to come, this is the window to plan for.
- The frozen winter valleyIn deep winter the valley and its streams freeze, and on a clear day you can walk carefully over stretches of ice. It is starkly beautiful, but only attempt it with your guide and only when the road is open and safe.
- Lachen village and monasteryBack at base, Lachen has an old Nyingma monastery and a slow mountain-village rhythm worth an evening. It is also where you rest and acclimatise, so do not overplan the day you arrive.
- On to Gurudongmar, if you are Indian and it is openFor Indian travellers, when the lake is open, Chopta is the pause on the very early drive up to Gurudongmar at about 17,800 feet. It is a sacred, staggering sight, but it is also serious altitude, so read the safety section first.
The one thing not to rushDo not treat Chopta as a photo stop between Lachen and Gurudongmar. The valley rewards a slow half hour on your feet far more than a quick window-down snap from the car. Breathe, walk a little, look at the small flowers or the frozen stream underfoot, and let the altitude and silence do their work. That unhurried pause is what turns a long drive into a memory.
06Where you actually sleep
Where to stay, and how the trip is built around Lachen
There are no hotels in Chopta Valley itself. You sleep in Lachen, usually one night, which also does the vital job of helping you acclimatise before the high run north.
- Lachen: homestays and small hotelsLachen has homestays, guesthouses and a handful of small hotels, from simple family-run rooms to a few more comfortable properties. Standards are basic to mid-range by design; this is a remote high village, so expect warm hospitality and hearty food rather than luxury.
- Nothing in the valley itselfChopta Valley, Thangu and Gurudongmar have no tourist accommodation. Everything is a day run out from Lachen and back, which is why the base village matters so much and why your night there is not optional.
- One night in Lachen is the standardMost North Sikkim trips build in one night in Lachen before the early high-altitude leg. That single night is your acclimatisation, so resist the urge to combine it with an even higher sleep, and take the evening slowly.
- Book through your operator, aheadBecause rooms are limited and the whole leg is permit-tied, your Lachen stay is arranged as part of the tour rather than walked up on the day. In peak spring and autumn, and around any Gurudongmar reopening, the good homestays fill fast, so confirm early.
Why the base village decides your comfortBecause you cannot sleep any higher than Lachen on this route, the quality of that one night shapes the whole trip. A warm room, a good dinner and an early, unbroken sleep at about 8,800 feet are what let you handle the thin air the next morning. Choose the Lachen stay carefully, arrive with enough daylight to rest, and you set yourself up for the high leg far better than any last-minute dash allows.
07What it costs
Chopta Valley and North Sikkim costs
This trip is bought as a package, not assembled on the ground. Here is what the main pieces cost, so you can judge a quote and understand what you are paying for.
- The permit is free; the trip is notThe Protected Area Permit itself costs nothing. What you pay for is the registered operator, the Sikkim-registered vehicle with a beat-permit driver, the Lachen stay and meals, and the guide. That is why North Sikkim cannot be done as a cheap independent add-on.
- Shared package ratesThe official Sikkim Tourism sharing rate for a 3 days 2 nights Lachen and Lachung trip starts at about 3,999 rupees per person, and private or peak-season market packages run up to about 8,000 rupees per person. A shared jeep may carry several travellers together, which keeps the cost down.
- Common add-onsExtra high points are usually charged separately; Zero Point beyond Yumthang, for example, is often about 500 rupees per person extra. Ask exactly which valleys and high points are included before you accept a quote, and whether Chopta and Gurudongmar are in the plan.
- Carry cash for everything up topThere is no reliable card or UPI acceptance beyond Lachen, and often no signal at all. Draw enough cash in Gangtok for tips, snacks, small purchases and any on-the-day extras, because up in the valleys plastic simply will not work.
08On the ground
Practical logistics: signal, cash, food and the drive
The small realities that make or break a high-altitude day, from the near-total loss of mobile signal to food, cash and the long hours in the vehicle.
- Signal drops away past LachenAirtel and BSNL work in patches around Lachen and cut out entirely higher up, and there is effectively no coverage at Chopta, Thangu or Gurudongmar. Tell family at home you will be offline for the high day, and download offline maps and music before you leave Gangtok.
- Cash, not cardsWith no reliable signal there is no reliable UPI or card payment beyond Lachen. Draw cash in Gangtok, keep small notes for tips and snacks, and do not count on an ATM once you are north of Chungthang.
- Food and waterMeals up here are simple, warm and mostly vegetarian at the homestays and roadside stops, often rice, dal, momos and hot soup. Drink bottled or boiled water, eat light on the high-altitude morning, and carry a few snacks and a full water bottle for the long drive.
- Long hours in the vehicleThe days are dominated by driving on rough mountain roads, often 6 to 7 hours in total on the big legs. Pack motion-sickness tablets if you are prone, take the front seat if you can, and build the pace your body needs rather than the operator's tightest possible schedule.
Dress and pack for real cold, year roundEven in summer the mornings at Chopta and Gurudongmar altitude are bitterly cold and windy, and in winter the Lachen belt can sit around minus 5 to 15 degrees Celsius. Pack warm layers, a windproof jacket, gloves, a woollen cap, sturdy shoes, sunglasses and strong sun cream whatever the month. The sun is fierce at altitude even when the air is freezing, so protect your skin and eyes.
09Altitude and staying well
Safety, altitude sickness, and the army timing
The real risk here is not crime; it is altitude. Chopta sits near 13,100 feet and Gurudongmar near 17,800, so an honest acclimatisation and health plan matters more than anything else.
- Understand acute mountain sicknessAbove about 2,500 metres, some travellers get acute mountain sickness within about 6 to 12 hours, showing as headache, nausea, dizziness, tiredness and poor sleep. At Gurudongmar's altitude the air holds only about 53 percent of the oxygen at sea level, so this is a genuine, common risk, not a rare one.
- Acclimatise in Lachen firstThe standard step is to spend a night in Lachen at about 8,800 feet before the high run. Do not fly in and rush straight to the top the same day. Sleep low, climb high and come back down, and give your body the overnight it needs.
- On the high morningStart early, keep the stay at the top short, and move slowly; do not run, jump or over-exert at the lake or in the valley. Stay well hydrated, avoid alcohol the night before, and eat lightly. Ask your doctor before the trip about altitude medication such as acetazolamide.
- Know the warning signs and descendA worsening headache, breathlessness at rest, confusion, or an unsteady walk can signal the serious forms, high-altitude pulmonary or cerebral oedema, which are emergencies. The only real cure is to go down at once. Tell your guide immediately and descend; do not push on for a view.
The before-noon army barrier, and who should not go highOn the Gurudongmar road the army generally does not allow vehicles past the barrier after about 10 am, which is why tours leave Lachen before dawn and aim to reach the high point before about noon. Take this timing seriously. And be honest about health: anyone with a serious heart or lung condition, uncontrolled blood pressure, or a pregnancy should get medical advice before going above 4,000 metres, and may be wiser to stop at Lachen or Chopta rather than push to Gurudongmar.
10Who it suits
Chopta Valley for every kind of traveller, and on access
This is a high, remote, permit-bound trip, so it suits some travellers far better than others. Here is a frank note for each, including an honest altitude verdict for seniors and children.
- Couples and honeymoonersThe emptiness and scale are quietly romantic, and the shared adventure of the high drive bonds people. Choose a comfortable Lachen homestay, and do not over-schedule; a slow evening at base is part of the charm.
- Families with children, honestlyYoung children can struggle with the altitude and the long drives, and cannot easily tell you how they feel. Many families enjoy Lachen and the lower valleys but think hard before taking a small child to 13,000 or 17,000 feet. Talk to your paediatrician first, and keep plans flexible.
- Senior travellers and on altitudeFit, well seniors do this trip often, but the altitude is the deciding factor, not the walking. If you have heart or lung issues or uncontrolled blood pressure, get medical clearance, consider stopping at Lachen or Chopta rather than pushing to Gurudongmar, and never rush the acclimatisation night.
- Photographers and birdersCome in spring for the bloom and the birds around Thangu and Chopta, or autumn for the sharpest peaks. Carry spare batteries, which drain fast in the cold, and remember there is no charging and no signal for long stretches up top.
- Solo travellers and foreign passportsSolo Indian travellers join shared jeeps easily through a Gangtok operator. Solo foreign travellers cannot get the permit alone and must be in a group of two or more, so plan to pair up or join an arranged group.
- First-time high-altitude travellersThis is a serious altitude for a first trip. It is doable with the right pace, but read the safety section properly, build in the Lachen night, and be ready to turn back at Chopta if your body says so.
- Day one: Gangtok to LachenLeave Gangtok early for the long, slow drive of about 107 km and 5 to 6 hours to Lachen, crossing into the permit belt at Chungthang. Arrive with daylight to spare, rest, eat well and sleep early. This night is your acclimatisation, so do not waste it.
- Day two: the high leg to Chopta and beyondStart before dawn to beat the army barrier. Drive up past Thangu, pause at Chopta Valley, and, if you are an Indian traveller and the lake is open, continue to Gurudongmar before turning back. Foreign travellers make Chopta and Thangu the turnaround. Return to Lachen or drive on to Lachung.
- Add Lachung and YumthangMost trips pair Lachen with Lachung and the Yumthang valley, which adds a day and a second high side of North Sikkim. A 4 to 5 day North Sikkim loop from Gangtok is far more comfortable than trying to squeeze Lachen into two days.
- The honest verdict on a short tripA 2 to 3 day Lachen dash is sold, and it works on paper, but it means 6 to 7 hours of daily mountain driving and thin acclimatisation. If you can spare the time, the slower loop is safer and far more rewarding.
Build the plan around the altitude, not the mapThe single thing that breaks a North Sikkim plan is treating it like a normal road trip. The distances look small, but the altitude, the permit timings and the fragile roads set the real pace. Keep the Lachen acclimatisation night sacred, leave early for the high barrier, and hold a spare day for weather or a road block. Plan around the mountain, and it rewards you; fight it, and you spend the trip anxious and unwell.
- Is this the same as Chopta in Uttarakhand?No. This is Chopta Valley in North Sikkim at about 13,100 feet near Thangu, reached only on a permit tour. The Uttarakhand Chopta is a forested trekking base at about 8,790 feet for Tungnath and Chandrashila. Two different places in two different states.
- Can I visit on my own without an operator?No. North Sikkim beyond Chungthang is permit-only, and the permit is issued only to travellers on a booked tour with a registered operator and a Sikkim-registered vehicle. You cannot self-drive or go independently.
- Can foreigners reach Gurudongmar Lake?No. Foreign passport holders can go only as far as Thangu and Chopta Valley. Gurudongmar is open to Indian nationals only because of the border. If you hold a foreign passport, plan Chopta as your northern goal.
- Is Gurudongmar open right now?It reopened to tourists from about March 2026, after more than two years shut following the 2023 glacial lake outburst flood, once a new bailey bridge over the Taram Chu restored the Lachen road. The road is still fragile, so expect short weather and landslide closures, especially in the monsoon. Always reconfirm the current status with your operator and Sikkim Tourism before you book.
- Is a 2 to 3 day trip enough?It is possible but hectic, with 6 to 7 hours of daily driving and thin acclimatisation. A 4 to 5 day North Sikkim loop is far safer and more comfortable, especially for the altitude.
- Is it safe for my elderly parents or my child?The deciding factor is the altitude, not the walking. Fit seniors manage it with a proper acclimatisation night, but anyone with heart, lung or blood-pressure issues should get medical clearance, and small children may be better kept at Lachen. Ask your doctor first.
13NRI and foreign travellers
Planning Chopta Valley from abroad, and the foreigner rules
For an overseas visitor, two facts shape everything: you cannot reach Gurudongmar, and you cannot travel this belt alone. Chopta Valley becomes your northern goal, and a little planning makes the permit easy.
- You go only as far as Chopta and ThanguThis is the fact to accept early: a foreign passport is not allowed beyond Thangu and Chopta Valley, and Gurudongmar Lake is closed to foreign nationals. Set your expectations on the valley itself, which is a magnificent goal, and you will not be disappointed at a checkpoint.
- You cannot travel soloThe Restricted Area Permit is not granted to a lone foreigner. You must be in a group of two or more and go through a Sikkim Tourism registered travel agent, supervised by a registered guide. If you are travelling alone, join an arranged group in Gangtok.
- Permit timing and validityThe North Sikkim permit runs a minimum of 3 days and 2 nights up to a maximum of 5 days and 4 nights, and your overall Sikkim stay is capped at 30 days, extendable in total to 60. The process for foreign nationals has been moving to digital clearance, so let your agent handle it and carry your passport original.
- Respect the altitude on a first tripIf this is your first Himalaya, the altitude is the real challenge, not the paperwork. Build in the Lachen acclimatisation night, do not rush, and be ready to make Chopta your turnaround for health reasons as well as permit ones.
Why Chopta is still worth the journey for foreign travellersIt is easy to feel short-changed that the lake is off limits, but Chopta Valley is a genuine high-Himalayan reward in its own right: a treeless valley at about 13,100 feet, blooming in spring and frozen in winter, as far north as almost any traveller gets on this frontier. Reframe it as the destination rather than a consolation, give it an unhurried pause, and it becomes one of the most memorable mornings of a whole India trip.
14Money, SIM and timing
Money, connectivity and timing for foreign visitors
The practical basics an overseas traveller needs for a remote, high, offline region: cash, a SIM that works only part of the way, and how to slot Chopta into a wider India trip.
- Get an Indian SIM early, expect to lose itPick up an Indian tourist SIM or an eSIM when you land in Delhi or Kolkata; foreign roaming and some networks are weak here. Even then, coverage fades past Lachen and disappears at Chopta and Gurudongmar, so treat the high day as fully offline.
- Carry cash from GangtokDraw cash in Gangtok before you head north. There is no dependable card or UPI acceptance and often no signal beyond Lachen, so cash covers tips, snacks and any on-the-day extras up in the valleys.
- How long to give it on a bigger tripOn a wider India or Northeast trip, give North Sikkim about 4 to 5 days from Gangtok so the altitude has room to breathe. Slotting a 2 to 3 day dash into a packed itinerary is where overseas travellers most often fall ill or get stranded by weather.
- Time it to the open, clear seasonsSpring, about April to June, gives you the bloom, and autumn, about October to November, gives you the clearest skies. Avoid the monsoon landslides of July to September and the deep-winter road closures unless you are prepared and flexible.
On a first trip to the Indian HimalayaNorth Sikkim is a demanding but unforgettable first taste of the high Himalaya: remote, permit-bound, offline and genuinely high. Come with realistic expectations, an acclimatisation night at Lachen, cash in your pocket and a spare day for weather, and let a trusted Gangtok operator carry the permit and logistics. Handled this way, Chopta Valley becomes the calm, staggering high point of an India trip rather than a stressful scramble.
15The Gurudongmar pilgrimage angle
Chopta Valley and Gurudongmar for Indian travellers
For Indian travellers, Chopta is the pause on the drive to Gurudongmar Lake, one of the highest and most sacred lakes in the country. Here is how to do the leg well, and reverently.
- Your permit is free, but book the tour earlyAs an Indian national your Protected Area Permit is free and arranged in a day by your Gangtok operator, but the Lachen stay and the vehicle fill fast in season. Book the North Sikkim leg well ahead, and carry a Voter ID, Passport or Driving Licence, since Aadhaar is often not accepted for this permit.
- Chopta on the way to GurudongmarWhen the lake is open, Chopta Valley is the natural pause on the very early drive up, and Thangu is the lunch stop. Reach Gurudongmar before about noon to beat the army barrier, spend only a short while at the top for your health, and let Chopta be the slower stop on the way back.
- A sacred, high placeGurudongmar at about 17,800 feet is revered across faiths, and a portion of the lake is held to stay unfrozen and holy in tradition. Treat it as a place of worship: do not litter, do not shout or play loud music, and follow your guide and the local customs at the water.
- If the lake is shut, Chopta still deliversGurudongmar reopened in about March 2026, but the fragile road still shuts for short spells in bad weather and the monsoon. On any day the lake is closed, Chopta Valley and Thangu become the northern turnaround. It is a shorter, gentler day at slightly lower altitude, and still a genuine high-Himalayan experience, so the trip is far from wasted.
ॐ
The legend of the road's endThe lake that will not fully freeze
The road past Chopta Valley ends at Gurudongmar Lake, and the lake carries one of the most loved legends in the Himalaya. In local tradition a great teacher passing this way was begged by the people of a parched, frozen land for water they could drink, and he blessed a part of the lake so that it would never freeze solid, leaving them living water even in the hardest winter. The lake is held sacred by Buddhists and by Sikhs alike, and its very name is linked in tradition to a revered guru. Which teacher the story names, Guru Padmasambhava or Guru Nanak, is told differently by different communities, and the WayToIndia way is to honour all these tellings rather than flatten them into one. Stand at Chopta on the way up, look at the bare, enormous land around you, and you understand why people reached for a miracle to explain a patch of water that stays alive at the roof of the world.